Category: Museums & Archives Catalog reference 2026.MA.0170

The National Toy Hall of Fame and Its Plush and Dolls

Of 91 toys in the National Toy Hall of Fame, one is a plush animal. A year-by-year check of the dolls and soft toys inducted at The Strong, how the selection works, and what its archive holds.

Filed under
Museums & Archives
Catalogued
Updated
Written by
Cut Rizka Maulida
Reading time
7 min read
Entrance of The Strong National Museum of Play in Rochester, New York, with the museum's sign on the facade and snow on the ground
Image: The Strong National Museum of Play in Rochester, New York, home of the National Toy Hall of Fame since 2002, photographed in February 2013. Photo: Ruhrfisch, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

The National Toy Hall of Fame has honored 91 toys since 1998, and only one of them is a plush animal. That toy is the teddy bear, inducted in the first class. Dolls fare better, with Barbie, Raggedy Ann, Cabbage Patch Kids, and several others on the roll.

We checked every inductee and year below against the official list at The Strong National Museum of Play in Rochester, New York. The list was current through the 2025 class when we compiled this guide. Where the museum’s own records disagree with each other, we point it out.

How the National Toy Hall of Fame Chooses Its Toys

The hall did not start in Rochester. According to The Strong’s FAQ, it opened in 1998 at A.C. Gilbert’s Discovery Village in Salem, Oregon, and moved to The Strong in 2002.

Anyone can nominate a toy online, all year. Nominations received by July 31 count for that year’s class. Later entries roll over to the next year.

The selection then runs in this order:

  1. An internal committee of curators, historians, and educators picks 12 finalists, announced in mid-September.
  2. A National Selection Advisory Committee of about two dozen historians, scholars, educators, and pop culture experts submits ranked ballots.
  3. The public votes in a Player’s Choice ballot, which counts collectively as one ballot.
  4. The inductees, usually three, are announced in early November.

The 2023 class was the exception. For the hall’s 25th anniversary, The Strong added a fourth toy from a group of long-time finalists it called the Forgotten Five.

The Four Criteria

The museum judges each nominee on icon-status, longevity, discovery, and innovation. The last one carries extra weight, as the FAQ makes clear.

“Innovation: the toy profoundly changed play or toy design. A toy may be inducted on the basis of this criterion without necessarily having met all of the first three.”

The Strong National Museum of Play, National Toy Hall of Fame FAQs

Plush and Dolls in the Hall, Year by Year

We read all 90 entries on The Strong’s inductee list. The count of 91 comes from one shared page: Raggedy Ann and Raggedy Andy appear together but were inducted five years apart. The table keeps only dolls, figures, and soft toys.

YearInducteeType
1998Teddy BearPlush animal
1998BarbieFashion doll
2002Raggedy AnnCloth doll
2004G.I. JoeAction figure
2007Raggedy AndyCloth doll
2008Baby DollDoll category
2015PuppetToy category
2020Baby NancyBaby doll
2021American Girl Dolls18-inch dolls
2023Cabbage Patch KidsCloth doll, later plastic heads
2024My Little PonyVinyl mini figures
Dolls, figures, and soft toys in the National Toy Hall of Fame, from The Strong’s inductee pages.

Two nearby inductees did not make the table. The dollhouse entered in 2011, the same year as the blanket, but neither is a doll or a stuffed toy.

Wide view of a gallery inside The Strong museum with a child-sized post office, play structures, a Wegmans store front, and families at tables
Gallery space inside The Strong, December 31, 2009. The layout shown has since changed. Photo: Davepape, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Teddy Bear, 1998

The teddy bear’s entry calls it “the most popular plush toy in history.” Our account of how teddy bears became popular covers the boardwalk prizes and magazine patterns the museum cites, so we will not repeat them here.

One detail is worth a collector’s attention. The Strong’s page spells the Brooklyn candy-shop owner’s name “Morris Mictom.” The Smithsonian and the National Park Service both spell it Michtom, so search both forms in the museum’s catalogs.

Raggedy Ann and Andy, 2002 and 2007

Raggedy Ann was inducted in 2002, and her brother followed in 2007. The museum ties her success to a 1918 book by Johnny Gruelle, sold alongside dolls by the publisher P. F. Volland.

Worn red cloth front cover of Raggedy Ann Stories by Johnny Gruelle, showing the rag doll in a blue dress and apron
Front cover of Johnny Gruelle’s Raggedy Ann Stories (P. F. Volland, 1918), the book the dolls were sold alongside. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons; scan from the Internet Archive.

Our guide to the antique Raggedy Ann doll dates the licensed makers who followed Volland. It is the better starting point if you own one.

Barbie and the Baby Doll

Barbie entered with the teddy bear in 1998. The Strong says she became the best-selling fashion doll of all time within a year of her 1959 debut.

The baby doll followed in 2008, as a category rather than a brand. Its entry contains a contradiction. The main text says the first baby doll appeared in the mid-1800s, the decades of the German china-head doll, while the “Factoyd” at the bottom of the same page says early 1900s.

The 1922 Bye-Lo baby, which the museum describes as modeled on a three-day-old newborn, sits clearly after both dates. For the longer story of dolls before Barbie, see our history of dolls.

Cloth Dolls and Soft Vinyl in the 1980s

Cabbage Patch Kids joined in 2023. The museum credits art student Xavier Roberts with the original fabric “Little People,” influenced by Martha Nelson Thomas’ Doll Babies. Coleco’s version with plastic heads reached stores for the 1983 holiday season.

My Little Pony, inducted in 2024, is harder to classify. Hasbro’s 1983 ponies were made of soft vinyl, and The Strong calls the line “the most popular of the mini doll lines between 1983 and 1992.”

Baby Nancy and American Girl

Baby Nancy, inducted in 2020, came from Shindana Toys in Los Angeles. The community-owned company launched in 1968, and sculptor Jim Toatley designed the doll’s face to have Afrocentric features.

American Girl dolls joined in 2021. The museum reports that the first three dolls, sold by direct mail, earned $1.7 million between September and December of 1986.

Why Are There No Stuffed Animals Besides the Teddy Bear?

Through the 2025 class, the hall has no general entry for stuffed animals and none for rag dolls. The teddy bear stands alone as a plush animal, and Raggedy Ann and Andy are the only cloth dolls named by character.

The criteria offer a likely reason, though the museum has not said so. The hall rewards toys that changed play, and the teddy bear set the pattern every later plush animal followed. A brand-name plush line would have to prove its own icon-status and longevity on top of that.

Puppets are the closest relative. The 2015 Puppet entry names Shari Lewis’s Lamb Chop and the Sesame Street characters, many of them soft cloth figures. If a plush character matters to your collection, check the Puppet page before assuming the hall ignores it.

What The Strong’s Archives Hold for Researchers

The hall is a small part of The Strong. Its Brian Sutton-Smith Library and Archives of Play holds a 264,000-volume research collection, including trade catalogs, business records, and personal papers.

Trade catalogs are the useful part for plush collectors. A dated catalog page showing a bear or doll is often the firmest evidence of when a design was sold, a point our vintage Gund teddy bear guide makes with labels and patents. The library runs separate online catalogs for books, archives, and digitized collections, so a search can start from home.

The display cases show only a fraction of the holdings. A 2024 post on the museum’s blog says only about 5 percent of the total collection is on view at any one time.

For collections built entirely around bears, our guide to teddy bear museums checks which ones are still open. The Strong covers play in general, so its strength for a bear collector lies in the archive more than the galleries.

Sources

  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “National Toy Hall of Fame FAQs,” museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Inducted Toys,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Teddy Bear,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Raggedy Ann and Andy,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Barbie,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Baby Doll,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Cabbage Patch Kids,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “My Little Pony,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Baby Nancy,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “American Girl Dolls,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Puppet,” National Toy Hall of Fame, museumofplay.org.
  • Smithsonian National Museum of American History, “Teddy Bear” fact sheet, americanhistory.si.edu.
  • National Park Service, “The Story of the Teddy Bear,” nps.gov.
  • The Strong National Museum of Play, “Brian Sutton-Smith Library & Archives of Play,” museumofplay.org.
  • Dina Garber, “A Day in the Life of a Conservation Undergraduate Intern,” The Strong, October 28, 2024, museumofplay.org.

Written by

Cut Rizka Maulida

Mostly History & Heritage ยท 9 records

Rizka writes about toy museums and archive collections, with an eye for what a visit actually shows and what sits in storage. Her guides cover opening details, signature exhibits, and the provenance of the bears on display.

All records by Cut Rizka Maulida
How to cite this article

Maulida, Cut Rizka. "The National Toy Hall of Fame and Its Plush and Dolls." Arctophile, May 23, 2026, https://arctophile.biz.id/national-toy-hall-of-fame/.

How we source

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

View all records